Musk’s Feud with Trump

The push for a new political party comes amid Musk’s public clash with President Donald Trump over the controversial “Big Beautiful Bill”—a tax-and-spend plan adding $2.4 trillion to the federal deficit. Musk lambasted the bill as a “disgusting abomination,” triggering Trump to threaten cutting federal subsidies to Musk’s companies.

Musk responded forcefully, tweeting, “Without me, Trump would have lost the election,” referencing his financial and digital support in 2024. This feud has since snowballed into a broader ideological rift, prompting Musk to propose a new party representing the “80% in the middle”—a centrist bloc he believes is ignored by both Democrats and Republicans.

Why a New Political Party? The Appeal to the 80%

Musk’s idea resonates with a growing, politically homeless demographic. According to Pew Research, an increasing number of Americans identify as independents, disillusioned by partisan gridlock and polarization.

The America Party seeks to speak directly to this group—emphasizing:

• Pragmatic solutions over ideological rigidity
• Fiscal responsibility without austerity
• Tech-driven governance using AI, live polling, and digital town halls

Unlike past efforts such as Ross Perot’s Reform Party, Musk’s resources and platform give his proposal unprecedented reach.

On X, suggestions poured in: some floated names like “Aam American Party,” others urged reforms like ranked-choice voting. One comment read, “Yes, 100%! We need a party that prioritizes smart policy over political theater.”

Challenges of Creating a Third Party

Despite the enthusiasm, structural barriers to a third party in the U.S. are formidable:

• The Electoral System: America’s winner-take-all format favors the status quo. Perot’s 1992 run garnered 19.9% of the vote—yet no Electoral College success.
• Leadership Limitations: Musk, not being a natural-born U.S. citizen, is constitutionally barred from running for president himself.
• Ideological Diversity: Defining the “80% middle” is elusive. Many are united by frustration, not cohesive policy views, which could fracture party unity.

Political analyst Anthony Scaramucci summed it up: “Ross Perot scared the daylights out of the two parties. They locked down after that. It’s nearly impossible unless the system changes.”

Public Sentiment and High-Profile Support

The viral poll—which has now passed 2.5 million votes—shows an appetite for something new. Billionaire Mark Cuban responded with ✔✔✔, signaling possible support. On X, one user wrote, “A new party focused on fiscal sanity and real outcomes is a necessity.”

However, Musk’s polarizing image could complicate matters. His approval among Democrats has plummeted to just 6%, per an NBC News poll. His recent stances on immigration and government spending have aligned more with the right, raising doubts about his ability to unify moderates and independents.

What Would The America Party Look Like?

If launched, The America Party could function like a Silicon Valley startup:

• X Spaces for live town halls
• AI-based candidate vetting
• Real-time user polls for shaping platforms

Musk would likely champion policies around innovation, deregulation, clean energy, and transparent governance. While that could excite younger, tech-savvy voters, it may alienate older or less digitally engaged citizens.

One user cautioned: “It’s easier to take over an existing party than start a new one from scratch.”

The Road Ahead: Disruption or Distraction?

Musk’s idea may or may not materialize into a formal political movement. But it undeniably highlights widespread voter disillusionment and distrust in traditional political institutions.

As Musk declared on X, “This is fate.” Whether that fate is the beginning of a true third-party revolution—or another bold but unsustainable experiment—remains to be seen.

Final Thought: Is the Middle Ready to March?

A new party for the “80% in the middle” is an alluring concept. With support from high-profile figures and millions of voters online, The America Party might just tap into the zeitgeist. But it will take more than digital excitement—it will require strategic alliances, legal groundwork, ideological clarity, and time.

Join the conversation:
Do you believe The America Party can disrupt U.S. politics? Follow NRIGlobe for updates and share your thoughts.