Taylor vs. Serrano 3: A Disappointing End to a Historic Boxing Trilogy

July 13, 2025 – The highly anticipated trilogy bout between Katie Taylor and Amanda Serrano, held on July 11, 2025, at Madison Square Garden, left boxing fans disheartened. Despite the electric atmosphere and the promise of another epic clash, Taylor vs. Serrano 3 failed to deliver the thrilling action of its predecessors, earning it a reputation as one of the most lackluster third fights in boxing history. Here’s a deep dive into what went wrong, the fight’s impact, and what’s next for these women’s boxing icons, exclusively for NRIGlobe.com.

A Historic Rivalry Falls Flat

Katie Taylor (25-1, 6 KOs) retained her undisputed super lightweight title against Amanda Serrano (47-4-1, 31 KOs) via majority decision (95-95, 97-93, 97-93) in a sold-out Madison Square Garden. The event, streamed live on Netflix, marked the first all-women’s boxing card at the iconic venue, featuring 21 world titles across five championship fights. However, the main event failed to live up to the legacy of the trilogy’s first two bouts in 2022 and 2024, which were both Fight of the Year contenders.

The first fight in April 2022 saw Taylor edge Serrano by split decision in a high-octane clash that landed 330 punches, while their November 2024 rematch set a CompuBox record with 541 punches landed. Fans expected another explosive encounter, but Taylor vs. Serrano 3 saw a mere 140 punches landed combined, with both fighters adopting cautious, tactical approaches. Social media echoed the disappointment, with one X user calling it “the worst fight of the trilogy” and another labeling it a “snooze fest.”

Why the Fight Disappointed

Unlike the aggressive, back-and-forth battles of their previous encounters, Taylor vs. Serrano 3 was a chess match marked by tentative exchanges and minimal risk-taking. Serrano, wary of potential headbutts after a cut in their 2024 fight, fought at long range, a strategy that played into Taylor’s strength as a precise counterpuncher. “I tried to keep my distance and not fight with her because apparently it didn’t work in the first two fights,” Serrano admitted post-fight.

Taylor, meanwhile, relied on her footwork and sharp jabs to control the pace, landing 70 of 231 punches compared to Serrano’s 70 of 382. Her accuracy (30.3% vs. Serrano’s 18.3%) likely swayed the judges, but the lack of sustained action left fans wanting more. Rounds were often too close to call, with no fighter dominating, and the expected fireworks never materialized. One X post criticized Serrano’s coaching, stating, “Her power is her strength, and she didn’t use it.”

The fight’s slow pace was a stark contrast to the historic all-women’s card, which included standout performances like Cherneka Johnson’s ninth-round TKO over Shurretta Metcalf and Ellie Scotney’s unanimous decision over Yamileth Mercado. Yet, the main event’s lack of intensity overshadowed these achievements for many fans.

The Legacy of Taylor vs. Serrano

Despite the disappointment, the trilogy remains a cornerstone of women’s boxing. The 2022 fight was the first women’s bout to headline Madison Square Garden, and the trilogy has elevated the sport’s visibility. “We’re history-makers forever,” Taylor said, acknowledging the cultural impact. Serrano echoed this, thanking fans for supporting women’s boxing.

However, the lackluster third fight has sparked debate. Some fans on X praised Taylor’s tactical brilliance, with one user noting, “This was the most clear-cut of the three fights. Taylor boxed her ass off.” Others felt cheated, with posts calling for refunds and criticizing the event’s hype. The consensus is that the trilogy, while legendary, ended on a low note.

What’s Next for Taylor and Serrano?

At 39, Taylor hinted at retirement, saying, “I don’t want to fight Amanda Serrano again. She punches too hard.” She may consider a trilogy with Chantelle Cameron to break their 1-1 tie. Serrano, 36, remains the unified featherweight champion and has options, though a fourth fight with Taylor seems unlikely. “The Serrano saga is absolutely finished,” Taylor stated, closing the chapter on this rivalry.

Final Thoughts

Taylor vs. Serrano 3 was a historic event that showcased women’s boxing on a global stage, but its cautious, low-output main event left fans yearning for the intensity of the first two fights. As both fighters move forward, their trilogy will be remembered for its cultural significance, even if the final chapter fell short. For the latest updates on women’s boxing and more, stay tuned to NRIGlobe.com.

Keywords: Taylor vs. Serrano 3, Katie Taylor, Amanda Serrano, boxing trilogy, Madison Square Garden, women’s boxing, undisputed super lightweight title, boxing disappointment, Netflix boxing, fight results